Alfie's Pizzeria - Jamaica

Beautiful Food, Beautiful service, Great choice if your after authentic Pizza from a family run business for now 50 years. Definitely a great choice. The pizzas were amazing and a great size too. You can choose by pizza or by slice along with some additional sides. Thank you for the Alfie’s experience. ?

Alfies is the best pizzeria in NYC! Not only is their food outstanding, but they also offer the option to create heart-shaped pizzas upon request. Thank you, Alfies!

I almost stumbled while walking outside; I've been trying to get here for two years now. There are two pizza places closer to me, but they're both disappointing. You can tell if a pizza is good by tasting the plain slice, and this place definitely delivers. The pizza has great flavor, a delicious sauce, and the perfect crispiness. I'll be returning for a full pizza soon!

Disappointing, unfortunately. Let me first start off by saying that I had very high hopes for this place as I was looking for a decent pizza spot in the area. Now, the food was fresh, inexpensive and appeared to be good quality. The portions were also generous. I ordered a large plain round pie, garlic knots and zeppoles. I could tell the sauce was made in house and fresh and had a lot of San Marzano tomatoes in it I appreciated that. But overall the food was lacking taste. Literally all three items were very bland. The pizza could have been cooked a little more but that’s subjective so I won’t factor that in. I think it was mainly lacking seasoning and olive oil. The garlic knots were also lacking the same thing and slightly over cooked. The zeppoles were a weird triangle shape, dry and barely had powdered sugar also very dry.

As a seasoned pizza enthusiast, I wholeheartedly recommend Alfie's. The sauce bursts with flavor and authenticity, while the cheese melts to perfection. However, the true magic lies in their dough—it's light, soft, and just the right thickness, with a crispiness that ties everything together like a classic New York pizza should. Now celebrating 50 years of mouthwatering delights, thank you, Alfie's, for an exceptional pizza experience!